Dermot Gallagher casts verdict on four big decisions in Leeds United defeat at Tottenham as ex-White fumes

Dermot Gallagher has delivered his verdict on four contentious refereeing decisions in Leeds United’s defeat at Tottenham Hotspur who were “very, very lucky” to see Harry Kane’s equaliser stand.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

Several of United’s players remonstrated with referee Michael Salisbury after Tottenham’s first of three equalisers in Saturday’s 4-3 victory for Antonio Conte’s side was allowed to stand. Kane netted from a 25th-minute corner to cancel out Crysencio Summerville’s opener but only after defender Clement Lenglet had barged into Whites keeper Illan Meslier who was left deep inside his net after punching the ball clear before Kane swivelled to score. Both Salisbury and Paul Tierney on VAR opted not to intervene and former Premier League official Gallagher felt Leeds were unlucky to see the goal stand.

"I think Lenglet clearly fouls the goalkeeper for me and the clue for me is that the goalkeeper is in the air,” said Gallagher on Ref Watch on Sky Sports News. "The goalkeeper is in the air, he has gone to play the ball, I think Lenglet goes into him and I think they are very, very lucky to have a goal. That's so out of kilter with what we see week in week out. The one thing you'd say we have is this suggestion that the goalkeeper is over-protected. Well, he wasn't there, I was surprised no foul."

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Asked why VAR had not intervened, Gallagher reasoned: "I can only presume that the referee has fed back to the VAR what he has seen, the VAR has looked at it and come to the conclusion that it's not a clear and obvious error."

'LUCKY': Harry Kane's equalising goal for Tottenham Hotspur against Leeds United. Photo by Justin Setterfield/Getty Images.'LUCKY': Harry Kane's equalising goal for Tottenham Hotspur against Leeds United. Photo by Justin Setterfield/Getty Images.
'LUCKY': Harry Kane's equalising goal for Tottenham Hotspur against Leeds United. Photo by Justin Setterfield/Getty Images.

Gallagher was joined in the studio by weekly guests Stephen Warnock and Sue Smith, neither of whom could understand the decision. Warnock was asked by host Rob Wotton if the goal should have stood or not and said without hesitation: "No. It was beyond me. Me and Sue were talking about this, this morning. Meslier is in a good position to punch the ball. But as soon as you get pushed, that ability to really punch the ball is weakened then so he can't get a real punch on it. He's pushed into the goal.

"I am in that camp where the keepers get too much protection. I think you can be a little bit physical with them to a certain degree. But when he's in the air, you cannot push him, you can't do that. And this is the one thing that's really frustrating me at times is what the on-field referee has said. The on-field referee has seen it from his angle. The VAR official gets the opportunity to see it from three, four angles.

“We've got a clear angle here that shows that Lenglet goes into him, causes an issue, it's a foul, clear foul. You've missed something. But from your angle it looks okay and it's like how can you not see that? And how can you not understand what impact that's having on the game as well? That's the frustrating part of it."

Hide Ad